Paul Aronson, an elderly sugar daddy wannabe was robbed and tied up by twin teenage sisters he met on a dating site.
Aronson, 85 year old, joined the SeekingArrangement.com where he met a younger, Shalaine Foster, 17. They met on this website which entices users to find their "Sugar Baby".
The elderly man from Manhattan went for a dinner date with Foster but it turned out to be a trouble experience for the man. Foster, with her twin sister, Shaina tied up Aronson to a coffee table for approximately 20 hours. The twins also stole his credit cards and $470 cash as revealed in court papers.
On Tuesday, the twins were busted and charged with kidnapping, burglary, robbery, assault and grand larceny.
Aronson, a retired lawyer signed up a few weeks ago in the sugar daddy website. He was about to meet Shalaine but was surprised on their meeting date when the other twin also showed up. The two splurged the stolen money for a make-up shopping spree.
The sugar daddy went back to his luxury five-story townhouse at E.38th St. in New York City with the two teens and then began the robbing.
"Defendant Shania Foster zip-tied informant's leg to a coffee table while defendant Shalaine Foster zip-tied informant's hands behind his back," said the court papers.
A friend of Aronson discovered the man tied up in coffee table and reported the incident to the police. Police were able to arrest the twins.
In a report by NY Post, the twins' lawyer said that the twins were the real victims. The teen girls' mother and brother also defended the two and denied all accusations against them.
The Foster twins were held without bail and both were discovered to have prior arrests.